Robert Govers

Social Media and Place Brands

Robert Govers - Thursday 07 February 2013 - 16:33 - 2984 x read
Social Media and Place Brands

By: Robert Govers, February 7th, 2013

Earlier this week I delivered a keynote speech at the Holland Marketing Congress (#hmc2013) organised by @NBTC, @AmsterdamRAI and @HSMAI_NL about Nations as Brands, Competitive Identity and Brand Holland. In short, my argument was (as usual) that to consider places (nations, regions, cities) as brands is not about logos, slogans and advertising campaigns but about developing structures, systems and strategies that will enable places to coordinate, stimulate and co-create initiatives (policies, projects, investments) that are relevant, distinctive and meaningful (competitive) and fitting and authentic (identity) (i.e. Simon Anholt’s Competitive Identity). Holland has got some work to do in this area, because although it is in 12th position in the Anholt-GfK Roper Nation Brands Index, and hence punches above its weight, particularly on perceptions of governance and export (incl. its icons of tulips, cheese and windmills), the story of The Netherlands is less known among audiences outside of Europe.

It is a ‘Twitter discussion’ later that afternoon at the conference (with
@JosVranken, @CvanTiggelen, @Lars__Sorensen, @jeroen_beelen, @IrisHannema, @SDeerenberg, @gbartling) that triggered me to write this blog post. In his presentation after the break, Rohit Talwar (@fastfuture) opined that nation branding is nonsense, referring to the national bragging commercials of countries advertising on CNN or BBC World, and the ‘brands’ that are just there so as to satisfy the consultants that design them. If one defines place branding by its current popular practice (i.e. logos, slogans and ads) without referring to the rapidly expanding academic body of knowledge (such as in the quarterly journal of Place Branding and Public Diplomacy) or places that apply more thorough approaches, then I agree with Rohit. However, he dismissed the brand-concept altogether arguing that in today’s age of social media, it is the bloggers and other active social media users that will build reputation. It was suggested, for instance, that if cities or countries want to build their culinary reputation they just have to invite food critics and bloggers to their restaurants. Obviously, endorsements, reviews and positive buzz about a country’s economic offering is essential (place image is indeed largely built through consumption experience and ‘word-of-mouth/mouse’), but it is rather naïve to think that food-critics and bloggers will have a major impact on the overall international brand awareness and reputation of a country, particularly in the short term. I tweeted that: “If you want bloggers/publics to "talk about you" you need to have stories that are interesting to share and that fit you”. @IrisHannema tweeted that this is rather obvious and she is right, but unfortunately, the obvious is often ignored. Also, I am not just talking micro-stories that generate immediate buzz, but also and particularly about the macro-story that consistently builds reputation over time.

‘Place branding’ should not primarily be about controlling design, packaging and messaging (as is often the focus in commercial branding), but about stimulating engagement. The big global media advertising campaign logic is indeed built on outdated ideas of government propaganda where one can control the channel and the message. Luckily, those days are over, but it seems that some are applying the same logic to social media, i.e. assuming that there is any way in which one can control what bloggers and sharing consumers are saying about you and how that builds a macro-story. Yes, the reputation of countries, cities and regions is, now more than ever, fully in the hands of citizens and global audiences, but it does not mean that one should not try to inspire, stimulate and facilitate consistent narratives. If local public, private and civil society stakeholders were to ask themselves what their city, region or country is for - what its historic, present day and future contribution is to the world; the one thing it should be famous for; its defining purpose – it should result in a compelling, relevant, and meaningful narrative. Not a long list of achievements and things to brag about - which are often only relevant to locals and immediate neighbours - but looking for that underlying national story, the genius of the people, rooted in identity, where there is always a defining purpose to be found, which will guide public, private and civil society actors as an organising cross-sectoral principle that should enable places “to project an unbroken stream of dramatic evidence that will give them the reputation they deserve” (
Anholt 2011). It is the link to rooted identity that is critical, because identity determines behaviour, which determines the way that people talk (and twitter, blog and share stories) about you, which determines reputation. So indeed, I agree with most of what Rohit said, that most of the current practice of nation branding propaganda is nonsense, but to look at places as brands and to devise a Competitive Identity programme is actually uniquely relevant in today’s age of social media.

See also our chapter in the forthcoming UNWTO Handbook on E-marketing.

Thank you
@SDeerenberg, @JosVranken, @NBTC, @AmsterdamRAI, @HSMAI_NL, @CvanTiggelen, @Lars__Sorensen, @MaartjeSchouten for the lovely orange tulips, Holland book and for organising a wonderful conference.
Latest Change by: Robert Govers on Sunday 14 September 2014 - 16:18

Comments

 (2013-06-25 09:52)
This comment is deleted
 (2013-10-03 02:04)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-04-20 06:55)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-04-30 03:17)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-04-30 03:19)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-06-01 09:22)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-06-10 03:07)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-07-03 05:45)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-07-19 01:21)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-08-04 13:04)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-08-04 13:04)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-08-19 08:54)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-08-25 08:00)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-08-25 08:03)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-09-01 06:18)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-09-05 03:09)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-09-05 06:47)
This comment is deleted
 (2014-09-06 14:56)
This comment is deleted
kaiely
kaiely -  (2014-09-14 09:04)
Please sit down to find a place in the state selfish Sneaker Online . Because of rotation so-so, and (curry and the salty taste) shumai That made seat without waiting in particular, I got there in the food line without so much of the legs of fair-skinned pork dumplings Adjust Exchange Nike Air Force 1 , corner Nidonburi. Total of 1300 yen. Rider who was Diforume as the name is active Nike Air Jordan , but that the money in the RPG I've ever played the conditions of the stage clear, and I feel the world Air Force 1 Men High , most of the action items balanced worst interoperability and unnecessary, but a hero This is because the game was left Nike Air Max. In addition to the Rider as fake, I touched the first RPG, RPG certainly something well, I'm Drake I'm wondering about is the time of year of elementary school Nike Basketball Shoes , the witch of the mountain blowing fire people that know-how was the name that refers the Dragon King to come out .... So, I try to validate the usual helmet selfish. They were basketball shoes in 1980 Nike Dunk Shoes , but in reality, with the permission flat card only in the good sense, worked quite well for skateboarding shoes too Nike Shox Shoes . Why is the evolution of skate shoes Dunk Air Jordan 10+14 , the characters have been added to symbolize the connection with the SB shoe. Nice single swollen tongue for better grip board air zoom, and hood, suede toe has now Nike Dunk. Kangaroo is special among animals.I think people have an image to go lame leap is often kangaroo. I do not see kangaroo View in Zoo just to go like every 1m Men's Air Max 1 , but many times the human being in order to run hundreds of miles just the repulsive force of the long Achilles tendon kangaroo'm a big difference to the kangaroo in the wild that figure is (Reference blog). We waited a few years and there will be a big one for the Air Jordan 5, 2013. Also, for a little 'time, we counted all the way color print of the elephant in the release of this for 23 years Nike Dunk Women High , but see the new details suggest further representation of the central theme of today. Three and AJIII synonymous with '1988 years that references give a new nickname to us through the show and gives off tag inspiration sample Nike Men's Shox R3 periodic table (premium leather lining) tongue inside sneakers 'V'3 Lab5 Air Jordan El as part of。
kaiely
kaiely -  (2014-10-12 08:58)
In order to enjoy more Sony products, Sony store is a retail store of Sony professional staff to introduce the tips to master and appeal of the product. Expand in three places Ginza Winter Boots Sale , Tokyo, Nagoya, Osaka this time, October 26 (Saturday), two days 27 (Sun), Sony Store Nagoya and Osaka, the new digital single-lens 7R 7, a digital camera Cyber-shot ( TM) DSC RX10 Making the extraordinary meeting experience of living in a hurry Uggs Bailey Button . The mirror-less camera with interchangeable lens (1) in the first place, there will be a full-frame image sensor of the world even 35 mm talk show by a professional photographer 7R Uggs Bailey Button Triplet , 7 is a compact (2) of about 407g The world's smallest and lightest. Orange Co., Ltd. and Partners with: (Negishi Kichitaro Chairman) Tohoku University of Art and Design Uggs Women Bailey Button : The (Koyama KaoruDo Chairman), Professor at the forefront of national and international instigator, and the creative way adult school, which aims to Haishutsu of designers who combines the business acumen Tokyo planning conception Campus: Founded in October of last year (President Koyama KaoruDo), I was offered this distribution autumn from September to be the second student for a total of 133 people participated in Tokyo Campus planning concept was developed in October of last year Uggs Women Fox Fur , change the content of a continuing study of the seats format program planning seminar for 10 people, designing gimmick people (the book that is registered art) [February 2011 Impress Japan ] and when offered in the Uggs Kensington 2011 Tokyo Campus planning concept, which also became a best-seller that won the second place in the category business plan Amazon in about a week after its release, Schedule 10 will be conducted as a schedule of 12 people Seminar extended to 12 people a seminary professor of human existence Uggs Knightsbridge . Also, this time, not just the size to attend the conference the current campus garden, also provided a form of Uggs Roxy Tall video distribution of students, who can not attend the residents at a distance, for those who can not attend the convenience of the calendar, the weather is indecisive attempt was made to form that can provide learning opportunities for addition, for those who can take the Department of selective examination in any Uggs Retro Cargo , and passed the examination of practice has trained students of the program planning workshop is 12 people, Satoshi Takamatsu Department that in order to solve the problems that have emerged in the earthquake which will also introduce a new mechanism to Uggs Adirondack participate Department Naoki Ito ', we will build a new company Uggs Jimmy Choo , you may need to schedule There is no doubt. By all means, I have to read the details, thank you for the coverage ○ 12 people planning seminars. I was invited. Friend went for the second year running at the same time Uggs Women New Arrivals , as well as this year, but will have the long-term hospitalization with diabetes last year, is a light-hearted journey is impossible as the physical strength of this year. Age Unknown over-flights to Haneda flights late at night through LAX LAS constrained Super Eco-wari including national rate of Okinawa to Haneda month ANA ANA HP Mylar so (Premier Member) (bachelor in Okinawa) my hobbies besides reading pachinko slot Uggs Women Sheepskin Cuff , I have purchased homes for Miyazaki. (Product received from a regular wholesaler or manufacturer) new product [degrees S]: [N] degree unused product. Intact with no evidence that he struck with a carpet or turf. goods of better quality to Uggs Mayfaire the extent that it is such a thing as the subtle signs in the grass, a mat, etc.: (including over-the-counter displays, even moving shelf, etc.) [A] degree. U.S. stock market has fallen. 15451.09 discount of $ 185.46, the Dow Jones Industrial Average ended trading at 3774.73 14.65 points weaker Nasdaq. Fed President Bullard of St. Louis, and saw out quantitative easing shrink and commented that it was the judgment of the last minute, and a distribution to decrease as a result of the fact that it has been suggested to undertake the reduction of Uggs Nightfall the FOMC meeting of October were. AS Junior gets results this season Chan people, and it was with being demoted in Nagoya Part B of the next fiscal year. I there are a variety of causes, but the member is not big enough for one. It is a state of just 11 people gather to game day.

Comment on this article

You must be logged in to leave a comment.

Subscribe via email

Follow the comments of this article by email: